Formerly Tony's

Loved it! We called up for delivery tonight and were very impressed with the taste and service. Would absolutely order from here again

This place makes such a delicious pizza I've made four take out orders within ten days of it reopening. My favourite pizza ever and it ain't even close.Toppings: plentiful, high quality and appropriately distributed. The pineapple had the right crunch, but wasn't soggy. The bacon was healthy pieces, cooked to perfection. Ham chucks were diced finely enough that there was a little in every bite and they didn't overpower either of the other toppings.Crust: Goldilocks style - not too crispy, not too doughy, juuuust right. Not too thick, not too thin, it was the precise thickness required to give you a satisfying crunch without being burnt. Sturdy enough that when you hold it one handed it doesn't flop all over. Look in my photos for how perfectly browned it was around the edges.Sauce/cheese: this two things were joined together in a culinary harmony that only enhanced the other two aspects above. The ratio of the two was so precise across the pizza, I suspect a Ph.D student wrote a thesis on how to distribute them optimally.What kinda madman writes a review this detailed about pizza? The type of fella who would divorce his wife and marry this restaurant.All 22,367 citizens of this great City need to experience the euphoria. If you haven't been in here, close your browser and get on the phone.Check the photos, place your order and you too will be saving Formerly Tony's under Best. Pizza. Ever." in your contacts."

It's too bad I live so far away from Lindsay, because this is the best hidden Little Treasure Pizzeria I've been to in what feels like ages. I only ordered a simple pepperoni and within a few short minutes I walked out with it and was not disappointed. Though all may not share my same taste, I like a pizza with a delicious sauce and a good crunch to it's crust and not burnt.

Picked up two small pizzas this evening. The ingredients were very light. Didn’t like the crust very chewy. Very little flavour.

Pick up store only, no seating.Staff was pleasant enough but only one person ran the front and kept me waiting while she took a call.Pizza was OK. Better than frozen but not very interesting. Needed more sauce. The cheese didnt add any flavour. At least they used real bacon and not the crumble.This pizza was the better after a day" type. The leftovers tasted better the next day. The sauce and the mushrooms were more pronounced and the crust didn't dry out and harden like other crusts."

Been coming here for years. When I lived in town it was the go to place to order. Order Extra Oregano and garlic on everything! Cause its free.Now I live out of town, can't justify driving in for a pizza, but will stop in for a slice when in town.Love it.

Quick & friendly service. We ordered a cheese pizza. The sauce was great, the cheese was great but the crust was just ok. But I would buy again, still better than a lot of the bad pizza in town.

Absolutely awesome zaaaaaa... they got allot of good specialty flavors and cooked to perfection...this place is sensationally rad....get down there

I bought a double cheese medium walk-in pizza and I won't order a pie from here again. More expensive than the best pie in town (a med. double cheese is over $20 here) and very little to no sauce. No wonder they questioned me twice on the dipping sauce...